Hedge Performance Falters in Cyclical Slump
Advertisements
The recent announcement from Jiangte Electric (002176.SZ) marks a significant moment in the lithium salt market as it reveals the anticipated earnings outlook for the upcoming fiscal yearThe company's prediction of a net profit loss in 2024, estimated between 236 million and 285 million yuan, indicates a reduced financial setback compared to the staggering loss of 400 million yuan from the previous yearYet, while this may seem like a positive step, it starkly highlights the challenges the company faces as it grapples with the ongoing fluctuations in lithium prices.
Initially celebrated as a shining star in the stock market back in 2021, Jiangte Electric has struggled in recent years, witnessing a significant decline in its stock value, which now sits at nearly 70% lower than its peakThis reflects the broader industry trends, where the lithium carbonate market has experienced a decrease in average prices by approximately 65% over the past year, placing immense pressure on companies operating within this sector
The reality remains that despite Jiangte Electric's efforts to mitigate losses, their situation is far from stable.
In their performance forecast, Jiangte Electric highlighted proactive measures taken during the reporting period, including the implementation of a futures hedging strategy for lithium carbonateThis approach aims to shield the company from the adverse effects of falling pricesThe hedging strategy, primarily focused on futures contracts for lithium and copper, seeks to provide stability amid significant market volatilityThe two transactions - selling lithium futures and buying copper futures - have shown a promising trend regarding Jiangte Electric’s financial bearingsHistorical data noted that in the first half of 2024, the company's derivative investments yielded approximately 20 million yuan in gainsAs the market continues to unfold, analysts predict that these derivatives may play a crucial role in alleviating the company's overall losses for the year.
One remarkable aspect of Jiangte Electric's strategy is its early entry into the lithium carbonate futures market
- Energy Crisis Meets Fed's Monetary Tightening
- Global Stock Markets Surge: Will A-Shares Follow?
- U.S. Inflation Nearing Its Peak
- Kunlun Wanwei's AI Ambitions and Hurdles
- Battery Firm Targets $1B Off-Road EV Market
As early as late April 2023, the company began to outline a risk management strategy to mitigate the impact of product price volatilityBy July 2023, after the official launch of lithium carbonate futures, Jiangte Electric was actively participating, albeit with a modest hedging scale initiallyHistorical announcements revealed that the company made investments totaling approximately 13.36 million yuan in commodity futures, just a fraction of what would later become a more substantial investment approach.
Fluctuations in lithium prices have been dramatic, particularly as the second half of 2024 approachesIndustry reports indicate that while lithium futures prices lowered by 1.57% in the first half of 2024, the latter half saw a more pronounced decline of 20.35%. This widening gap paints a bleak picture for companies still reeling from the previous price dipsIf Jiangte Electric can effectively maintain its hedging strategy, it stands a strong chance of counteracting some of the fiscal pressures brought on by the market's sharp decline.
However, the anticipated asset impairments for the year, totaling 188 million yuan, suggest that factors beyond hedging may also be at play in Jiangte Electric's balancing act
With many lithium salt producers in Jiangxi province facing significant production reductions, there is an underlying concern that Jiangte may also struggle with decreased sales volumesIn the first half of 2024, the prices of battery-grade lithium carbonate plummeted by around 65%, while Jiangte Electric reported an astonishing 82.03% drop in revenue from its lithium mining and salt manufacturing sectorThis stark revenue loss underscores the harsh realities of the market and places additional strain on the company's already weakened financial state.
As the lithium industry grapples with an evolving cycle, Jiangte Electric has witnessed notable changes in its revenue structure over the past three yearsDuring the peak of the market in 2022, their lithium salt product revenue soared to over 5.3 billion yuan, accounting for a whopping 80% of the company's overall revenueUnfortunately, this figure dwindled dramatically by mid-2024, dropping to just 213 million yuan amidst a broader industry downturn
Although prospects for future growth remain closely tethered to the lithium and salt sectors, questions linger on how to recalibrate operational strategies to regain footing.
Moreover, one of the key factors contributing to Jiangte Electric's operational difficulties is its reliance on externally sourced raw materials, which has historically led to elevated production costsReports from 2022 and 2023 show that Jiangte's unit costs for lithium salt standing at 170,900 yuan and 192,600 yuan per ton were significantly higher than its peersThis dependency has not only hampered profitability but also exposed the company to adverse fluctuations in pricing as witnessed during the lithium price drop in 2023, when Jiangte was among the first lithium salt producers to report losses.
Conversely, promising developments related to the Xikeng lithium mine have emerged, which could signify a turning point for Jiangte Electric
The mine boasts a higher overall grade than many competitors and has received mining rights since May 2024, a development that Jiangte Electric regards as a "milestone" for its lithium industry expansionUpon commencing operations, the mine is expected to enhance the company's lithium ore self-sufficiency, thereby reducing production costs and increasing competitive viabilityHowever, this crucial development does not guarantee immediate profitability, as market dynamics and production costs remain complex and nuanced across the industry.
As it stands, the competitive landscape necessitates a delicate balancing act for Jiangte Electric, particularly as other lithium extraction firms exhibit wide variations in production costs due to differences in resource quality and self-sufficiencyRecent reports indicate that the lowest production costs in the industry hover around 50,000 yuan per ton at Yongxing Materials, whereas other companies, including notable players like CATL, are facing costs significantly exceeding 80,000 yuan per ton
In January 2025, the domestic battery-grade lithium carbonate market price oscillated around 76,000 yuan per ton, implying meager profit margins available primarily for select established players.
These realities beckon the question: how much downward pressure can Jiangte Electric's operations withstand as it strives to optimize its lithium salt production costs? The answer remains uncertain, and while market oscillations indicate a possible shift towards a more stable supply-demand relationship by 2025, the futures market reveals a prevailing lack of compelling upward momentum for the lithium salt industry overall.
As Jiangte Electric embarks on this transformative journey, it must carefully navigate through the fog of market uncertaintiesThe reality of potential profitability within its core business hinges upon a multitude of factors, and the upcoming quarters will reveal whether the strategies in place are adequate to turn the tide
Leave A Comment